Odalis Perez, Julio Cesar Pimental, Blake Johnson, and cash have been sent to the Royals in exchange for Elmer Dessens.
I don’t know how I feel about this deal until we find out how much “and cash” is, so stay tuned.
The “and cash” is reported to be eight million dollars. Odalis’ current contract is as follows:
Signed 3-year deal worth 24M thru 2007 season on 1/7/05- He receives a 4.5M signing bonus payable between November 2006 and Nov. 2007- + He will make salaries of 3M in 2005, 7.25M in 2006 and 7.75M in 2007- + The deal includes a Team Option for 2008 worth 9M or a 1.5M buyout- + he can earn performance bonuses in 2006, 2007 and 2008: 150K each for 185 and 200 IP and 200K for 215IP
All told, Odalis was owed his entire 4.5 million signing bonus, 3.625 million for the rest of this year, 7.75 million for 2007, and a 1.5 million dollar buyout, for a total of 17.375 million dollars. The eight million in cash drops that to 9.375. Meanwhile, Dessens is owed 2.55 million through the end of 2007, bringing the total money saved to 6.825 million. So, the question is, is Elmer Dessens and 6.825 million dollars worth Odalis, Blake Johnson, and Pimentel. It’s hard to say.
Neither Johnson nor Pimentel seem all that valuable in my eyes, as they both struggled in Vero Beach in their age 21 seasons. Pimentel’s strikeout rate is promising, but he has no control. Baseball America sees something in them, as they were named the number 16 and 17 prospects in the organization, ahead of players like Cory Dunlap, Xavier Paul, and Willy Aybar. Overall it seems rather silly to predict the future of people putting up mediocre numbers in A ball, so I can’t consider them a huge loss.
That leaves the question is Odalis Perez worth Elmer Dessens and 6.85 million dollars? Dessens is putting up his usual numbers, below average strikeout rate, decent control, and keeps the ball in the park relatively well. Perez, as we all know has been terrible. His strikeouts have declined to an even five per nine, and balls are leaving the park at a rather poor 1.36 per nine rate. In his favor, he still has a good walk rate, and his BABIP is an obscenely high .372. Anecdotal evidence seems to confirm he was getting unlucky, as he seemed to give up a lot of dinky singles, which he would make worse by giving up a home run shortly there after.
I hate to get into mental factors, but the way Grady jerked around Odalis has to be a factor. After pulling him from the rotation after only six starts, three of which were very good starts where he only gave up one run, OP went up to two weeks between appearances. That generally doesn’t lead to successful pitching. I’d like to keep Odalis around because he was a good pitcher at one point, unlike Hendrickson or Tomko, but it’s entirely possible he’s done.
Honestly, I can’t call this trade either way. If Odalis comes back, and is able to produce at even a Mark Hendrickson like level, the Dodgers probably lose, but it’s entirely possible that he won’t. I liked Odalis when he was here, he produced some good memories like his one hitter, and when he struck out Barry Bonds by quick pitching him, but watching him struggle this year was completely brutal. The upside seems to lie with the Royals, they’re getting two decent prospects and a guy who’s had far more success than any starting pitcher in their rotation, while the Dodgers side of the deal isn’t going to get any better than it is today. However, seven million bucks is halfway to a nice free agent, and I like nice free agents.